Schuyler Lake Mall/Tenant list/Former tenants

Anchor stores

 * Alexander's (1983 to 1992)
 * B. Altman (1983-1988; now The Village Food Court)
 * Babies "R" Us (1998-2018; now Child World)
 * Best Products (1977-1996; now P.C. Richard & Son, current occupant still retains the SITE-designed "slanted exterior")
 * The Bon-Ton (1994-2018; now andThat!)
 * Carrefour (1991-1993; now Walmart Supercenter, current occupant's exterior still largely resembles that of the former occupant)
 * Chase-Pitkin (1983 to 2005)
 * Just for Feet (1998-2004; now Guitar Center, current occupant still maintains a similar exterior)
 * Montgomery Ward (1977 to 2000; now Burlington)
 * Kaufmann's (1990-2006; now Macy's)
 * Sibley's (1977-1990; later Kaufmann's)
 * Toys "R" Us (1983-2018; now Boscov's, was planned to be turned into one of the "Geoffrey('s Toys "R" Us)" concept stores at one point in the early 2000s, but the plans never materialized)

Junior anchors

 * Best Products (1977 to 1996)
 * Chuck E. Cheese's Pizza Time Theatre (1983 to 1985)
 * Kaufmann's Kids Store (1990 to 2006)
 * Old Navy (1997-2021; was originally Chuck E. Cheese's Pizza Time Theatre from 1983 to 1985 and a Sibley's/Kaufmann's Clearance Center from 1985 to 1996) [outparcel]
 * Sib's Kids by Sibley's (1977 to 1990)

Inline stores

 * Brothers: The Endless Adventure (late 2011-2015)
 * Carls Drugs (1983-1991; later became Fay's Drugs)
 * Club Libby Lu (2005-2008; now FYE, current occupant still retains the old exterior with the original silver & blue colors)
 * Disney Store (1992-2021) [Neighborhood 3]
 * Early Learning Centre (1987-1991)
 * Eckerd (1996-2006; now Rite Aid)
 * Fay's Drugs (1991-1996, was Carls Drugs)
 * GameStop (2005-2021; was Babbage's from 1991 to 2005)
 * Gymboree (1991-2018; now Rail Raiders)
 * Justice (2005-2020; now Gilly Hicks)
 * Lady Foot Locker (1991-2021)
 * MovieStop (2005-2016; now Docomo Northeast Store)
 * Nickelodeon Store (1997-2002; now Hollister/Social Tourist)
 * KB Toys (now Uniquo)
 * P.S. from Aeropostale (2010-2014; now It'Sugar)
 * Rite Aid (2006-2021; was a Fay's Drugs from 1991 to 1996, then Eckerd from 1996 to 2006, didn't have a pharmacy)
 * Ruehl No.925 (2007-2010; was a Toys "R" Us Express during the 2011 Black Friday season, now Men's Warehouse retaining the old "house" exterior)
 * Sailor Schuyler's Gift Harbor (1992-2007; later Brothers: The Endless Adventure)
 * Sanrio Gift Gate (1992-2007; later P.S. from Aeropostale)
 * Sesame Street General Store (1992-1996; now Hot Topic)
 * Sleepy’s (1991-2016; now Mattress Firm)
 * Tower Records (now Zumiez)

Dining

 * Aerodome (rotating restaurant atop the Sibley's/Kaufmann's/Macy's; 1977-2012, relocated by helicopter to the top of Schuyler Lake Speedway's new score pylon where it operates to this day)
 * Bugaboo Creek Steakhouse (2000-2013; now HuHot Mongolian Grill)
 * Friendly's (1983-1997; replaced with Kahunaville)
 * Kahunaville (1997-2006; now IHOP)
 * Lord Kensington's Old English Fish & Chip (1977-1999; replaced with Bugaboo Creek Steakhouse)
 * TCBY (1991-2006; now Subway)

Food court

 * Burger King (1991-2009; now Tim Hortons)
 * Dippin' Dots (2001-2015; closed as Dippin' Dots/Doc Popcorn opened on floor 2)
 * Manchu Wok (1991-1997; now Panda's Wokery)
 * Roy Rogers (1991-2009; now Best Kabobs)

Entertainment

 * Discovery Zone (1994-1999; now H&M)
 * Great Eskate (roller/ice skating rink; 1977-1981, later a B. Altman)
 * NASCAR Speedpark (2001-2009; Later Nitro Family Kart Raceway and Fun Center)
 * Nitro Family Kart Raceway and Fun Center (2010-2020)
 * Ripley's Believe It or Not (1997-2012; formerly Wegmans Adventures in Family Fun)
 * Sesame Place New York (1991-2011) [Neighborhood 5]
 * Sailor Schuyler's Play Ship (1991-2007)
 * Skytram (1977-1996; a suspended monorail that went around the mall, scrapped during the 1997 remodel)
 * Wegmans Adventures in Family Fun (1991-1995)