New Super Mario All-Stars

Default

 * Super Mario Bros. (1985)
 * Super Mario Bros. 2 (1988)
 * Super Mario Bros. 3 (1988)
 * Super Mario World (1990)
 * Yoshi's Island (1995)

Unlocked After Beating Super Mario Bros.

 * Mario Bros. (1983)
 * Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels (1986)
 * Super Mario Bros.: 16-Bit (1993)
 * Super Mario Bros. Deluxe (1999)
 * Super Mario Bros. Redux (2021)

Unlocked After Beating Super Mario Bros. 2

 * Super Mario Bros. 2: FDS Version (1987)
 * Super Mario Bros. 2: Beta Version (1988)
 * Super Mario Bros. 2: 16-Bit (1993)
 * Super Mario Bros. 2: Advance (2001)
 * Super Mario Bros. 2: Redux (2021)

Unlocked After Beating Super Mario Bros. 3

 * Super Mario Bros. 3: 16-Bit (1993)
 * Super Mario Bros. 3: Advance (2003)
 * Super Mario Bros. 3: Redux (2021)
 * Super Mario Bros. 3: Pacifist (2021)
 * Super Mario Bros. 3: No Power-Ups (2021)

Unlocked After Beating Super Mario World

 * Super Mario World: Beta Version (1989)
 * Super Mario World: Advance (2002)
 * Super Mario World: Redux (2021)
 * Super Mario World: Pacifist (2021)
 * Super Mario World: No Power-Ups (2021)